Typically, Instagram Stories that appear at the start of your feed are from accounts that you engage with the most, whether that’s through likes, comments, story views, reactions, or sliding back and forth in the DMs.
If you regularly engage with an account, their new stories will be bumped to the front of your feed every time they post, even if you’ve watched all their stories from the previous day.
Ask questions, create polls, create a community, talk to your audience when they message, create trust. So in a nutshell? MAKE STORIES ENGAGING. Or… Let us do that for you.